City
Epaper

SC slams ED's handling of Shivakumar's bail plea (2nd Lead)

By IANS | Updated: November 15, 2019 21:35 IST

The Supreme Court on Friday slammed the Enforcement Directorate (ED) for doing a shoddy job of "copy and paste" when challenging the bail granted to ex-Karnataka minister and Congress leader D.K. Shivakumar referred to him in the petition as "former Home Minister and Finance Minister".

Open in App

A bench headed by Justice Rohinton Nariman said: "This is not the way you treat the citizens."

The bench expressed its anguish after Shivakumar's counsel, senior Advocates A.M. Singhvi and Mukul Rohtagi noted the contents of the petition in question had been copied from the petition filed against senior Congress leader P. Chidambaram, who is currently lodged in jail.

The apex court thereafter junked the ED's petition challenging the Delhi High Court order granting bail to the Congress leader from Karnataka.

The court also expressed its unhappiness after being informed by the counsel representing Shivakumar that the ED has "resurrected" the stringent Section 45 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), which was quashed in 2017.

The court had held this section as violative of the right to liberty. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta contended that Rs 142 crore of laundered money was recovered in this case, but the apex court did not accept his contention.

Justice Nariman, who delivered the minority judgement in Sabarimala review, told the Solicitor General to advise the government to read the judgement passed by the top court in the Sabarimala case on Thursday.

"Tell them our judgements are not to be played with," said Justice Nariman.

He told the Centre that an impression has been created that its officers don't comply with court orders. Justice Nariman also asked the Solicitor General to apprise the Centre and its officers of his dissenting judgement in the Sabarimala case.

"Ask your government and its officials to carefully read our judgement in Sabarimala. Tell them our judgements are not be played with. Kindly instruct your officers to read what the court has said about Article 141," said the judge.

According to Article 141, the law declared by the Supreme Court shall be binding on all courts within the territory of India.

"Our orders must be complied with. We won't allow any violation," the judge said.

( With inputs from IANS )

Tags: SabarimalaShivakumarcongress
Open in App

Related Stories

MumbaiBandra Fort Party Controversy: Viral Video Sparks Political Row as Sena UBT, Congress Question Alcohol Event at Heritage Site; CM Fadnavis Reacts (Watch)

NationalTarn Taran Assembly By-Election 2025: 23.05% Voter Turnout Recorded Till 11 AM in Punjab By-Poll

MaharashtraSatara Doctor Suicide: Youth Congress Protesters Detained at Mumbai’s Marine Drive (Watch video)

MumbaiBMC Elections 2025: Congress to Contest Independently, Says Vijay Wadettiwar

NationalJubilee Hills Assembly By-Election 2025: Holiday Declared for Schools and Govt Offices; 139 Drones Deployed

National Realted Stories

NationalSelf-styled ‘Major’ among 4 militants arrested in Manipur; huge cache of arms seized

NationalHuman-elephant conflict escalates in Jharkhand; five people killed in a week, two elephants found dead

NationalCentre approves new Rs 7,712 crore investment under electronics component scheme

NationalKerala HC lambasts Vijayan govt for shielding accused in cashew import corruption case

NationalArmy Chief Gen Dwivedi says Manipur situation has 'significantly improved' since President's Rule