Supreme Court English news | Supreme Court, Latest News & Live Updates in English | English News (Latest English News) at Lokmattimes.com

New Delhi, Sep 14 The Supreme Court was told on Wednesday that Karnataka government order (GO) disallowing hijab will spell death knell for students desirous to take secular education, and the counsel, representing some of the petitioners further queried what is the degree of discipline affected by allowing someone to wear the hijab?Senior advocate Huzefa Ahmadi contended before a bench comprising justices Hemant Gupta and Sudhanshu Dhulia that most of the girls wearing hijab come from conservative families and queried what will be the natural fallout of this, and what is the degree of discipline affected by allowing someone to wear the hijab?He vehemently argued that the state's legitimate interest is to encourage diversity and not have uniformity in all practices and why should someone feel that someone's religious observances obstruct secular education or unity?Ahmadi argued that the state government order against wearing of hijab in schools misunderstands the concept of fraternity, and by prohibiting hijab in schools, the state government has virtually forced Muslim girl students out of school. He added that there was no legitimate interest of the state in imposing a ban. Huzefa said the GO, even if it appears to be neutral, has to be struck down for running foul of Article 14 of the Constitution. "If it targets a particular community," he said, adding that certain students from a community have broken the stereotype and went to school with a headscarf.Huzefa emphasised, "The GO will strike a death knell for their (students') secular education" and contended that disallowing hijab would create barriers for education and fraternity. He said it would go contrary to the principle of fraternity in the preamble of the Constitution, if it is said that hijab would not be allowed.Citing PUCL report, Ahmadi submitted that several students dropped out of school after the Karnataka High Court judgment on hijab on March 15. However, the top court expressed reservation on the neutrality of the report.Huzefa said if somebody is being provoked by girls wearing hijab that person should have a sense of brotherhood and fraternity.Earlier during the day, senior advocate Rajeev Dhavan, representing some petitioners, submitted before the top court that once it was shown that wearing a hijab is a bonafide practice then it was permitted, while citing the apex court's decision in the Bijoe Emmanuel case. Dhavan said that the conclusion of the Karnataka High Court was puzzling, as it said hijab was not mandatory due to the absence of prescription of penalties.The bench queried Dhavan that his argument was that the courts were not equipped to decide the matter, and if a dispute arises then which forum will decide it? Dhavan said what was the dispute? Whether hijab was an essential practice? He added that hijab was worn all over the country, and as long as it was bonafide and prevalent, the practice must be allowed and there was no need to refer to the religious text.On September 12, Senior advocate Yusuf Mucchala, representing petitioners in the hijab ban case, told the Supreme Court that Karnataka High Court faulted by opining wearing of the headscarf is not an essential practice of Islam, since the court had no expertise in the filed suit, it should not have gone into issue whether hijab was an essential religious practice by interpreting the Quran.The hearing on the petitions challenging the Karnataka High Court's judgement of March 15 upholding ban on Hijab in pre-university colleges will continue on Thursday.Disclaimer: This post has been auto-published from an agency feed without any modifications to the text and has not been reviewed by an editor

Supreme CourtFOLLOW

Supreme court, Latest News

New Delhi, Sep 15 The Supreme Court on Thursday said the right to establish educational institutions is a ... ...

New Delhi, Sep 15 The Supreme Court on Thursday said that convicts who have spent 10 years in ... ...

New Delhi, Sep 15 Senior advocate Colin Gonsalves on Thursday told the Supreme Court that the Karnataka High ... ...

New Delhi, Sep 15 Chief Justice of India U.U. Lalit on Thursday said that teething problems are bound ... ...

New Delhi, Sep 15 The Centre has told the Supreme Court that the medical students, who returned from ... ...

New Delhi, Sep 15 Senior advocate Dushyant Dave on Thursday told a two-judge bench of the Supreme Court ... ...

New Delhi, Sep 14 In a landmark decision, the Supreme Court on Wednesday allowed the Board of Control ... ...

New Delhi, Sep 14 The Supreme Court was told on Wednesday that Karnataka government order (GO) disallowing hijab ... ...