City
Epaper

SC to decide CA Act validity only after violence stops

By IANS | Updated: January 9, 2020 12:20 IST

The Supreme Court on Thursday said it will hear petitions questioning the validity of the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) as soon as violence which erupts at protests over the legislation stops.

Open in App

A bench headed by Chief Justice S.A. Bobde and comprising Justices B.R. Gavai and Surya Kant said there is already so much violence involved in the protests.

The Chief Justice observed that the country is already going through difficult times, and the endeavour should be to restore peace, and such petitions in the matter do not help the cause.

The court's observation came on the mentioning of a petition filed by an advocate Vineet Dhanda seeking the listing of his plea to declare CAA constitutional and also direction from the court to all states to implement it.

Dhanda moved the apex court to defend constitutionality of CAA, and also sought action against activists, students, media houses spreading "false rumours".

The court, putting a query to the lawyer, said: "Who wants CAA to be declared 'constitutional', and how can this court declare that an Act passed by the Parliament is constitutional?"

The court observed that there is always "a presumption of constitutionality, and being a student of law, you should know".

The court also observed that it was unusual to hear somebody seeking a declaration from the court that an Act is constitutional.

The bench said that the job of court is to determine validity of a law and it is not its job to declare it constitutional.

( With inputs from IANS )

Tags: CAASurya Kant
Open in App

Related Stories

Fact Check: Old Gorakhpur CAA Protest Video Wrongly Linked to Sambhal Violence

NationalCitizenship Amendment Act: Government Clarifies Document Requirements for Citizenship Under CAA

NationalAssam: Only Two People in State Have Applied for Citizenship Under CAA, Says CM Himanta Biswa Sarma

NationalCAA: Tripura Govt Forms State-Level Committee for Granting Citizenship Under Citizenship (Amendment) Act 2019

NationalFirst Set of CAA Certificates Issued: 14 People Given Indian Citizenship by MHA

National Realted Stories

NationalResidents in Dehradun reap benefits of Jan Aushadhi Kendra, express gratitude to Modi govt

NationalBharatiya Kisan Union (Ekta-Sidhupur) protests against Punjab govt for not giving compensation for destroyed crops

NationalHaryana Minister inspects arrangements for water drainage in Gurugram

National'We must stand as one': A plea for peace after the Pahalgam attack

NationalFour of family killed as car hits bike in Madhya Pradesh