Several supreme court, Court

New Delhi, March 23 The Supreme Court on Wednesday set aside the conviction and dismissal from service of Lt Gen S.K. Sahni (retd), who was Indian Army's Director General, Supplies and Transport, in an alleged ration scam.A bench of Justices L. Nageswara Rao and B.R. Gavai said: "We, therefore, find that the orders passed by the learned AFT (Armed Forces Tribunal) as well as the GCM (General Court Martial) are not sustainable in law. The appeal of the appellants (Union of India and others) deserves to be dismisseda."Justice Gavai, who authored the judgment on behalf of the bench, said: "The petitioner (Sahni) is acquitted of all the charges leveled against him; and the petitioner would be entitled to all pensionary and consequential benefits in accordance with law. The arrears of such benefits shall be computed and paid to the petitioner within a period of three months from the date of this judgment."The bench quashed and set aside the February 18, 2011 order passed by the GCM holding Sahni guilty and imposing penalty on him, and also the October 10, 2013 order passed by the AFT, directing his dismissal from service.The bench noted that the AFT has specifically come to a finding that he did not commit any fraud or any act, which resulted in actual loss or wrongful gain to any person."We are unable to appreciate as to on what basis the learned AFT comes to a conclusion that the acts lead to an inference that the attempts were made to cause a wrongful gain. The finding as recorded by the learned AFT is totally contrary to the material placed on record," it said.A court of inquiry, under the direction of the Army's Western Command chief, was ordered against Sahni based on a complaint received in April 2005. The court of inquiry was tasked to investigate allegations, which included procurement of kabuli chana, tendering and procurement of barley crushed and gram kibbled, tendering and procurement of 979 metric tonnes of masoor whole, etc.,Sahni retired in September 2006. His counsel argued that the findings as recorded by the GCM as well as the AFT are recorded on the basis of conjectures and surmises. He argued that like a criminal trial, the benefit of doubt must go to the officer and not to the prosecution, however in the present case, the GCM as well as the AFT have given the benefit of doubt to the prosecution.The bench said: "It is not the case of the appellants that the kabuli chana so supplied was of inferior quality or not as per the standards. The only allegation is that the relaxation which was granted was with regard to the number of grains that every 100 grams should contain."The bench pointed out that on account of reduction in price, there has been a substantial saving to the public exchequer, leave aside any pecuniary gain to the supplier."As a matter of fact, even the GCM, in paragraph (26), held that the respondent (Sahni) was entitled to benefit of doubt with regard to his intent but has found that the said act was prejudicial to good order and military discipline," it noted.The Centre and others had moved the top court against AFT order, which reduced the sentence of three years rigorous imprisonment and cashiering imposed on Sahni to dismissal from the service.Disclaimer: This post has been auto-published from an agency feed without any modifications to the text and has not been reviewed by an editor

Several Supreme CourtFOLLOW

Several supreme court, Latest News

In a major relief to former Mumbai Police Commissioner Param Bir Singh, the Supreme Court on Thursday transferred the investigation of the cases filed against him to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). ...

New Delhi, March 24 A Kashmiri Pandit organisation has moved a curative petition in the Supreme Court seeking ... ...

New Delhi, March 24 The Supreme Court on Thursday issued notice on a plea filed by suspended Additional ... ...

The Supreme Court on Wednesday acquitted a former Lieutenant General of Army from all charges, including irregularities in the procurement of ration by Army purchase organisation. ...

The Karnataka Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai announced that it has been unanimously decided in an all-party meet that local bodies polls will be held only after providing reservation for Backward Classes. ...

The Supreme Court on Wednesday passed the order directing the Central Empowered Committee (CEC) to examine and submit its report in a matter where the Rail Vikas Nigam Limited (RVNL) has sought permission to fell 5,094 trees for a railway line projec ...

Kerala government on Wednesday told the Supreme Court that the Mullaperiyar dam is not safe and if it breaks down then may lead to catastrophic results. ...

New Delhi, March 23 The Supreme Court on Wednesday set aside the conviction and dismissal from service of ... ...