City
Epaper

The young Chennai lawyer who waged a lifelong battle against 'freebies'

By IANS | Published: August 21, 2022 11:03 AM

Chennai, Aug 21 At a time when political establishments in the country are talking about freebies, it was ...

Open in App

Chennai, Aug 21 At a time when political establishments in the country are talking about freebies, it was a city based late young advocate S. Subramaiam Balaji who had crusaded against it.

Balaji crusaded against the populist freebies announced first by the DMK party and followed by rival AIADMK in Tamil Nadu and later by several other parties in the country.

He began his crusade petitioning the Tamil Nadu government, the Election Commission of India and then approached the Madras High Court and after that the Supreme Court.

It was a very long battle which he had lost at every step but Balaji was unfazed as he was of the firm view that private assets cannot be created out of public funds.

He had said announcing freebies is a corrupt practice under Section 123 of the Representation of People's Act.

The apex court in 2013, while not banning freebie schemes, had ordered the Election Commission to frame guidelines for political parties to announce freebies in their election manifestos.

Balaji had strongly felt a golden opportunity was lost to reign in political parties from creating private assets out of public money to be in power.

The top court had observed that promising freebies in the election manifesto doesn't amount to a corrupt practice under Section 123 of the Representation of Peoples Act, while ordering the Election Commission to frame guidelines for political parties.

The court gave the ruling after Balaji filed a case against the distribution of free colour television sets by the DMK to the people as part of its pre-election promise in 2006.

In an attempt to outdo the DMK, the AIADMK then under late J. Jayalalithaa promised mixers, grinders, fans and laptops and other freebies during the 2011 assembly polls.

Cheap rice, free TV, free power, free stove, cash dole promises by political parties is nothing but "bribery", Balaji had contended.

A government cannot enrich private individuals out of consolidated funds. Giving free land or free TVs or monthly cash doles are precisely that, Balaji had said.

Responding to one of his complaints, the poll panel took the stand that a declaration of public policy or a promise of public action - like giving away free colour TVs - was an offence under Section 171-B of the IPC.

Food is one of the three essentials for a person to live. It comes under public policy. But a colour TV is not an essential item, he had said.

Taking on the high and mighty was not new to Balaji.

It was his public interest petition in the Madras High Court that brought in the Central Bureau of Investigation

Disclaimer: This post has been auto-published from an agency feed without any modifications to the text and has not been reviewed by an editor

Tags: AiadmkElection Commission Of IndiaThe election commission of indiaState elections commissionState law commissionState election commission of indiaThe state election commissionState election office
Open in App

Related Stories

NationalLok Sabha Elections 2024: EC Asks Jairam Ramesh To Share Details of Claim on Amit Shah Calling Up DMs

NationalLok Sabha Election 2024: EC Sends Notice to BJP President JP Nadda and Congress Chief Mallikarjun Kharge, Asks Both Parties To Exercise Restraint

NationalElection Commission Issues Show Cause Notice to Abhijit Gangopadhyay for His ‘Sexist’ Remarks Against CM Mamata Banerjee

NationalLok Sabha Election 2024: EC Issues Advisory to Parties, Says Don’t Register ‘Beneficiaries’ for Future Schemes

NationalLok Sabha Election 2024: BJP Receives Five Consecutive Votes in Assam? ECI Fact-Checks Viral Video, Clarifies Misinformation

Politics Realted Stories

PoliticsWest Bengal Assembly By-Elections 2024: TMC Releases List of Candidates for July 10 By-Polls

MaharashtraMaharashtra Assembly Election 2024: Taking Control of State Is My Endeavour; NCP (SP) Must Win Assembly Polls for That, Says Sharad Pawar

PoliticsCID Summons Former CM BS Yediyurappa To Appear for Questioning in Pocso Case

Politics'Will Prime Minister Visit Manipur Now?' Uddhav Thackeray Questions After RSS Chief's Statement

NationalOdisha: BJP Government Oath-Taking Ceremony Rescheduled to June 12 Due to PM Modi's Busy Schedule